By SeafoodSource staff
Published on Monday, May 09, 2011
Editor’s note: The following is a letter to the editor submitted in response to SeafoodSource’s coverage of the ocean acidification issue, including the 6 October story “Acidification a growing threat to oysters” and the 1 February story “Ocean acidification: We’re down but not out.” The letter is also posted on the Gloucester Fishermen’s Wives Association website.
The oceans provide food for the world. As fishermen, growers, employers, and participants in the seafood industry, we are gravely concerned about the silent toll that ocean acidification has begun to take on marine resources. Seafood supplies, and our jobs and businesses, depend on healthy oceans.
That’s why we support continuation of the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI). RGGI helps to reduce carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from large power plants in the 10 states from Maryland to Maine.
These emissions don’t just foul the air. They mix into the oceans and increase the acidity of seawater. More than 30 billion tons of CO2 poured from the world’s tailpipes, smokestacks and cleared lands in 2009, mostly from burning coal, oil, and gas. In seawater the CO2 forms carbonic acid. The acid depletes the ocean’s rich soup of nutrients that support shellfish, corals, many plankton species and the marine food webs that underpin the world’s seafood supply.
Solid scientific measurements show that the extra acid from billions of tons of CO2 emissions already has changed the oceans, causing a 30 percent increase in the concentration of corrosive hydrogen ions in the ocean’s productive surface waters. Multiple studies and hard experience in the shellfish industry firmly demonstrate that CO2-acidified seawater undercuts growth, reproduction and survival of many species that provide food, livelihoods and recreational fishing for millions of people. Photos show that tiny larvae of hardshell clams dissolve and die within days in the acidified conditions found today in parts of many bays where nutrient loading from freshwater runoff further aggravates this change in seawater chemistry. The increased acidity in the rest of the ocean may already be harmful to some of the seafood species we harvest. A 2009 study at Stonybrook University showed that half as many young hardshell clams survive in seawater under present-day CO2 levels (390 parts per million CO2) when compared to pre-industrial conditions (250 ppm).
Even species that can endure some acidification are likely to suffer from the erosion of their more vulnerable prey and habitat. Among species known to be directly or indirectly vulnerable are lobsters, scallops, oysters, haddock, salmon, squid, krill and corals.
Reducing the emissions that cause this problem is critical if the oceans are to continue producing abundant seafood. By creating cost-effective incentives and limits on coal pollution from utilities, the RGGI program helps to safeguard stable supplies of seafood, and many thousands of jobs in the Northeast.
By any objective measure (and contrary to the overheated rhetoric from some quarters) RGGI works, it does not break the economy, and it does not kill jobs or infringe on freedom. By charging utilities for each ton of CO2 they emit and providing incentives for cleaner power and greater efficiency, RGGI has contributed (along with other factors) to a dramatic 33 percent reduction in CO2 emissions from the region’s electric power plants compared to 2005. Has the region gone broke as a result? Far from it. In fact, RGGI has added so little to retail electric rates that most ratepayers don’t even notice it: the tab amounts to 0.9 percent of retail power bills. And there is good evidence that RGGI has helped to stabilize industrial employment in the Northeast, in part by funding efficiency improvements that make factories more cost competitive, allowing them to keep workers employed.
Seafood is a major engine of jobs and economic activity in the United States and within the RGGI region. From the fish deck to the restaurant table, the business of producing, distributing and serving seafood generates more than USD 68.3 billion annually in the United States, much of it in the populous RGGI region. In New York state alone, a 2001 Sea Grant study estimated that this industry supported more than 100,000 jobs.
The Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative may not be perfect, but it should be maintained and strengthened, not scrapped. The RGGI system is a useful measure to keep ocean acidification from getting much worse, and that helps protect seafood supplies and jobs. We urge you to support this important program and oppose legislative efforts to scrap it or withdraw from it.
President, Maine Lobstermen’s Association
South Thomaston, Maine
President, Gloucester Fishermen’s Wives Association
President, Sea View Lobster Corp.
Mark Green, Ph.D
shellfish grower and researcher
Peaks Island, Maine
fisheries and community consultant
Blue Hill, Maine
Owner, F/V Thrasher
South Thomaston, Maine