The Canadian government must make a greater financial commitment to improving inadequate fisheries monitoring in its Atlantic provinces, according to a report jointly produced by environmental nonprofits Oceans North and the Ecology Action Center.
The report, titled “At-Sea Observer & Electronic Monitoring in Canada: Creating a robust and reliable monitoring program to support Canada’s commercial fisheries,” highlighted how weak monitoring continues to hinder sustainability efforts and may be thwarting efforts to grow and expand the nation’s Atlantic fisheries.
Oceans North Senior Fisheries Advisor John Couture, who co-authored the report, explained that Canada’s at-sea observer program began to deteriorate over a decade ago when the federal government pulled funding and mandated the industry to assume the full costs of the program. At-sea observation continued to decline during the Covid-19 pandemic, he said, and today, observers are employees of independent companies.
Of all species fished in Atlantic Canada, Couture said none are currently meeting at-sea observation targets, which can range from 5 percent to 100 percent and cover longline, seine, trawl, and handline fisheries.
The report cited a 2023 assessment by the federal Commissioner of the Environment and Sustainable Development, which found that Fisheries and Oceans Canada (DFO) has failed to implement the government’s fisheries monitoring program and had not completed a full assessment of monitoring programs for 156 key commercial marine fish stocks.
“This is not an isolated issue. This is a region-wide issue, and we need a more broad approach to finding solutions,” Ecology Action Centre Fisheries Program Manager Holly Isnor, who also co-authored the report, told SeafoodSource.
The need to find solutions stems from the fact that inadequate monitoring can lead to fishery closures, Couture cautioned, such as the historic 1992 moratorium on cod fishing and recent closures in Atlantic Canada’s mackerel fishery, while deficiencies in fishery data can also place eco-certifications in jeopardy, reducing market access and leverage for producers.
Isnor said monitoring programs in Canada have historically relied on an insufficient program of human observers hired to document fishing methods, bycatch, and collect scientific information.
To mitigate the issue, the authors proposed a combination of human at-sea observers performing manual tasks and electronic monitoring tools that provide baseline fishery data.
The proposed system would see the DFO adequately staffed to coordinate monitoring policies and the establishment of mandatory timelines, corrective actions, and public reporting for fisheries that fail to meet monitoring targets. Electronic monitoring standards would also be developed with costs shared and tailored to specific fisheries, taking into account specific factors such as vessel size.
The current human at-sea observer program could also be improved through an increase in recruitment, supported by higher wages and safer working conditions. According to the report, companies currently providing at-sea observers reported that last year, 75 observers were needed to meet minimum monitoring requirements – far above the 30 to 50 observers currently active.
Though technology such as vessel tracking and video monitoring are available, cost remains a key barrier to expanding their use, Isnor said.
“This has been a years-long conversation of how we address this issue in the region, and I think we've spent a lot of time talking about the challenges. We need to look at short- and long-term solutions at this point,” she said. “I hope that the report and the recommendations that we've made here will be useful for moving that forward.”
Isnor said the industry needs a commitment and investment from DFO, but the federal government under Prime Minister Mark Carney may have missed an opportunity earlier this month to sufficiently fund an expanded monitoring program when it released its budget on 5 November.
“My first take is that there wasn't a lot related to improving fisheries monitoring, and by a lot, I mean nothing,” Isnor said. “There was no mention of fisheries monitoring in there. I think that it is on DFO’s radar as a department, and there are definitely things happening within the department to try to move this forward, unfortunately with little resources. We really need an investment at the federal government level to address this.”