US lawmakers oppose Pacific Fishery Management Council proposal to end sardine rebuilding plan

Pacific sardine
In September, the PFMC proposed eliminating subpopulation designations for Pacific sardine, instead managing the species as a single stock | Photo courtesy of Martin Prochazkacz/Shutterstock
4 Min

U.S. representatives Jared Huffman (D-California) and Zoe Lofgren (D-California) are pushing back against the Pacific Fishery Management Council’s (PFMC) plan to definitionally merge two Pacific sardine subpopulations into a single stock, effectively eliminating a rebuilding plan for the northern subpopulation.

“A change in the stock definition should not be used to prematurely terminate rebuilding obligations or weaken precautionary safeguards before the scientific and management consequences of that change have been fully evaluated,” the lawmakers said in a joint 11 November letter. “Finalizing this ill-advised proposal would set a harmful precedent for other federally managed fish stocks by establishing an exit strategy to subvert the rebuilding requirements of [the Magnuson-Stevens Act].”

The northern subpopulation of Pacific sardines has been listed as overfished since 2019. NOAA Fisheries initially introduced a rebuilding plan for the stock in 2021, but conservation NGO Oceana sued, claiming the plan was inadequate. A federal court sided with Oceana, and NOAA Fisheries was charged with rewriting its rebuilding plan for the stock. In 2025, six years after the stock was first declared overfished, NOAA Fisheries finalized a new rebuilding plan, limiting the annual catch of sardines to 2,200 metric tons. Unlike the first plan, the second plan was supported by Oceana.

In September, however, the PFMC proposed eliminating subpopulation designations for Pacific sardine, instead managing the species as a single stock.

“Newly available scientific literature on Pacific sardine, including genetic studies and a review of all preceding research on Pacific sardine population biology, reveals a lack of scientific evidence to support any population structure, including the long-held hypothesis that [the northern and southern subpopulations] are distinct subpopulations,” the PFMC stated.

That change would effectively end the rebuilding plan for the northern stock, which would no longer be considered overfished under the new definition.

In their 11 November letter to the PFMC, Huffman and Lofgren questioned the council’s proposal and urged regulators to maintain the protections in place to help the northern subpopulation rebuild.

“We are concerned with the implications and consequences of the Pacific Fishery Management Council’s proposed action to redefine the Pacific sardine stock managed in the Coastal Pelagic Species Fishery Management Plan,” the representatives said in the joint letter. “While [NOAA Fisheries] has supported this effort as part of its implementation of President Trump’s Executive Order 14276, 'Restoring American Seafood Competitiveness,' weakening conservation and rebuilding safeguards before the stock has recovered would be misguided and counterproductive. Revising the definition of the overfished sardine population in a manner that eliminates rebuilding requirements before it has recovered would undermine the effectiveness of [the Magnuson-Stevens Act].”

Oceana has also opposed the council’s effort to unify the sardine subpopulations.

“Fishery managers are looking to strip sardines of critical protections as the population continues to nosedive to dangerously low levels,” Oceana Senior Scientist Geoff Shester said in a release. “Pacific sardines are the energy bars of the ocean and critical for whales, dolphins, salmon, and other marine life. As El Niño and other stresses bear down on the Pacific, it would be incredibly shortsighted and dangerous to now make management changes that push sardines into deeper collapse. We call on the Pacific Fishery Management Council to uphold the rebuilding plan and maintain the safeguards that will allow sardines a real chance to recover.”

Subscribe

Want seafood news sent to your inbox?

  Subscribe to SeafoodSource News

Editor's Choice